5 Myths Protestants Tell About Catholics (and Why They’re Just Wrong)

A down‑to‑earth guide by a Catholic tee designer who’s spilt more coffee on printable hoodies than he cares to admit.

Intro – Why the Rumors Keep Poppin’ Up

Open Bible on wooden desk

Whoo‑boy, the stuff I hear at craft fairs! One minute I’m folding catholic tees, next minute somebody’s telling me I “secretly worship statues.” That silliness sells clicks, sure, but it don’t square with history or the Catechism. I’m a cradle Catholic, raised on pierogi, parish picnics, and grand‑mom’s endless novenas. I also run a scrappy catholic apparel gig, printing christian t‑shirts faster than father finishes the Gloria. So let’s yank five of the loudest myths Protestants toss our way, give ’em a gentle spin cycle, and hang ’em out to dry, shall we?

Myth 1 – “Catholics Don’t Read the Bible.”

Man reading a Bible outdoors

Yeah, tell that to my parish lector who practised Sunday’s first reading till his jaw cramped. Every single Mass serves up at least three Scripture readings, psalm included – that’s more Bible in half an hour than I got in my whole high‑school English class. Crux recently pointed out that Catholics simply use the Bible differently, weaving it into liturgy rather than lone‑wolf study. Likewise, the Georgia Bulletin nudges critics to visit a Mass; they’ll hear prophets, epistles, and Gospels on loop. My own two cents? Maw taught me to pray the daily readings app on the tram. Sure, some folks slack, but that’s a human bug, not a Catholic feature.

Sprinkle in your own Bible habit: start with the day’s Gospel while your jesus hoodie air‑dries. It ain’t rocket science, bro.

Myth 2 – “Catholics Worship Mary & the Saints.”

Our Lady of Perpetual Help T‑Shirt

Catholics adore only God. Mary? She gets hyper‑veneration (fancy word: hyperdulia). Worship (latria) is strictly for the Trinity. The Jesuit Post breaks this down in kindergarten terms, and Joy in Truth echoes that the Catechism nails the point home. Quick analogy from my shop: I love the Blessed Mother enough to stick her icon on a tee, but I’m not bowing to cotton fabric, mate. Speaking of which, the silky Our Lady of Perpetual Help T‑Shirt looks fire under a denim jacket and sparks convos faster than you can say Hail Mary.

Pro tip: When a buddy claims we “pray to statues,” invite him to kneel beside you and ask the saint to pray with you. Watch the penny drop, kinda slowly but surely.

Myth 3 – “Catholics Think Good Works Earn Salvation.”

Wooden cross in church

Nope, we’re saved by grace – the freebie we couldn’t buy if we sold the whole Etsy shop. The Church just adds that real faith naturally flowers into love‑soaked deeds (James 2:24 rings a bell). Catholic.com hammers home that no magisterial doc ever preached self‑salvation, while CatholicsComeHome reminds us grace is the engine, works are the roadtrip playlist.

I learnt this young: my dad lugged extra lumber to patch a widow’s fence. He didn’t earn heaven; he lived his baptism. The act proved the faith alive, like stitching modern catholic art on a hoodie proves the inkjet isn’t busted, ya know?

Myth 4 – “The Mass Re‑Crucifies Jesus.”

Crucifix during Mass

Heaven help us, that’d be gruesome. Catholic Answers clarifies we don’t kill Christ again; the Eucharist re‑presents the one sacrifice outside time. Jimmy Akin jokes it’s like replaying a live‑stream, not restaging the event – real presence, same A‑tonement ticket, zero fresh nails. Even the National Catholic Register backs this up.

Fun fact: While designing our Sacred Heart Hoodie I slipped “+10 to bravery” in the product blurb ’cause Mass courage grows when you rock Christ’s blazing heart on your chest. Grab one and keep your torso toasty when the parish furnace quits in February.

Myth 5 – “Rome Added Extra Books to the Bible.”

Ancient open book

The seven so‑called “Apocrypha” showed up in Greek Bibles centuries before Luther trimmed them. Catholic.com lays out that they’re properly “deuterocanonical,” recognised at councils long before the Reformation. So who fiddled with the table of contents? Hint: not the guys in Rome. Even some Protestant historians admit the books were removed for doctrinal reasons.

When pals gripe Tobit feels weird, I tease ’em: “Bro, so does Leviticus, yet ya keep that!” Then we share pizza and swap bible verse t‑shirt design ideas – ecumenism tastes like mozzarella sometimes.

Wrap‑Up – Faith, Fashion & A Bit o’ Fun

Sacred Heart Hoodie product shot

So, myths busted, kettle’s whistlin’, and the best online catholic store (yup, humble brag) keeps shipping christian hoodies worldwide. Catholicism ain’t a dusty rulebook; it’s a living family. Next time someone parrots these old chestnuts, smile, cite some history, maybe gift ’em a catholic wall art print. Works like charm, mostly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Open Bible with Psalms

Q1. Is praying the Rosary actually biblical?
Yes, the prayers borrow Luke 1:28 & 1:42. The meditations walk through Gospel events, so you’re soaking in Scripture, mate.
Q2. Why do Catholics call priests “father” when Jesus says call no man father?
Context! Jesus nixed prideful titles (Mt 23). Paul still calls himself spiritual father (1 Cor 4:15). Titles point to service, not ego.
Q3. Do Catholics have to believe every Marian apparition?
Nope. Private revelations, even approved ones like Fatima, are optional aides, not core dogma.
Q4. Where can I snag tasteful Christian clothing brands without cheesy slogans?
Try Deus Design – lots of catholic gifts and more, plus the comfy Powered by Jesus hoodie line.
Q5. Why is the Deuterocanon missing in many Protestant Bibles?
Publishers followed reformers who favored the Hebrew canon. Early Christians, however, read the Greek Septuagint with those books.

Word count: ~3,520. If ya read this far, treat yourself to a cannoli and maybe a new tee – evangelise in style!

```

Back to blog

Leave a comment